Maybe I’m losing it.
Songwriting for me the past few years has been a big challenge. I have written a few songs and posted them on my ReverbNation page (http://www.reverbnation.com/mitchmatthews), but I keep downing myself because I’m not as proficient as I was in my 30’s. Back then I was playing in/leading a country-influenced alternative band (what today we would call Americana music), and I could easily write a song a week that I was proud of. Heck, I was writing for a female lead singer.
I took on the reins of songwriting in my bands then because no one else had the will to do it. I never wanted to be in a cover band. All of my bands did play covers, but we were selective about the songs, and wanted to stress our originality.
As I phased out of the band-member role and considered myself more of a songwriter, this was about the same time that I delved happily into my love for bluegrass music. I found that many of my previous compositions could transfer well to bluegrass, so I have recorded some in that vein. My writing style changed as well toward the bluegrass format.
Back in 2011 or so, when I attended the IBMA World of Bluegrass Conference, I started meeting other people like me – not into playing much but working more with songwriting. It was a great experience, and I was rewarded with co-writes with two people now more prominent in the bluegrass industry as songwriters.
However, I have struggled getting any more recognition. Part of the reason is that I have a full time job in Detroit, so I am not able to travel to Nashville (let alone live there) more than twice per year. I try to hit as many bluegrass shows as possible using my time off so that I can network with touring bands, but I hit a lot of brick walls by not getting any feedback.
In a recent online discussion at SongwritingPro.com, the topic of discussion came up regarding networking as well as the quality of the demo recording to give to a prospective artist. Like I said, I try to network in any way that I can, so that was not a concern. However, recordings of demos has always been a burr in my saddle.
When recording one of my demos, I usually have just guitar, bass, and vocals, with either some harmony vocals or another instrument (mandolin, dobro). I would think as a song, giving it to an artist or producer, that would be sufficient. However, many still want a full band recording.
Think about it. A bluegrass band, no matter how great or even unique they are, all have the same basic set-up of guitar, bass, banjo, mandolin and fiddle, give or take an additional instrument. Is it necessary for me as the songwriter to do the job as producer/arranger so that the artist can hear what the song sounds like in a full band setting?
I have mentioned this phrase before in previous blogs – “It all starts with a song.” A good artist or producer should be able to hear a good song in its rawest form and know what he/she wants to do with it. “1952 Vincent Black Lightning” is a great example. Richard Thompson recording his version was just his fingerpicking guitar and vocals. The Del McCoury band heard a hit with the song, THEN recorded it as a band.
Knowing that I may have to up front money to get a band to record my song demo (and try to find reliable bluegrass musicians willing to learn an original song here in the Detroit area) gets to be defeatist. With that, I tend to lose energy to want to write some more. I have loads of tidbits of songs in my notebook, but I find myself staring at them and not being motivated.
I have plans to hit Nashville in November to use up some vacation time, and have been contacting people down there for possible songwriting sessions or even just meetings. So far I have one “maybe.” It is two months away, so it’s not like I am calling on them last minute. It gets frustrating, but I realize that I am not well-known in the industry, only having one minor songwriting hit and a few other non-bluegrass writing credits.
We shall see how this all plays out.
Chew on it and comment.



