NOTE: This blog is not for the estblished bluegrass musician. It is meant for the absolute newbie.
Surfing on the internet, I came across a topic that piqued my curiosity: What is the best/easiest instrument for a beginner bluegrasser to learn?
Think about the six most common instruments in a bluegrass band – guitar, bass, banjo, mandolin, fiddle and dobro. Each one has its pros and cons for a beginner, and while some bluegrass musicians seem to be more than competent on almost off of the instruments, beginners struggle to be OK on one.
Guitar – The backbone of a bluegrass band. Most leaders of the band are armed with the acoustic guitar. These are also the most available, with entry-level models for under $100 to boutique models in the many thousands. Since the guitar is popular with other genres besides bluegrass, lessons for learning the instrument are numerous as books, videos and online, as well as in-person at pretty much any musical instrument store. Learning the basic chord fingering can be easy or a struggle, depending on the student (when I teach guitar, I usually have the student concentrate on working with the first three strings, then adding the fourth, fifth and six strings in due time). Unless you are planning on being the next Billy Strings or Molly Tuttle, keeping it to rhythm playing is accepted by others. The one problem is that, at jams especially, 75% of the jammers are playing guitar, so it can drown out the rest of the ensemble.
Bass – The world of bluegrass still seems to think that only an upright bass is permissible in a bluegrass band, despite many successful bands using an electric bass guitar. The upright bass is big and bulky, hard to travel with unless you have an SUV or pickup truck, and is fretless, so fingering takes a lot to work on. It is also hard to find even a mid-quality upright for under $1,000. A fretted electric bass makes life easier for the beginner until skilled enough to take on the upright. As the heartbeat of the band, keeping time and tempo with the root/fifth-note progression is of most importance. While an electric bass can be found for as little as $100, with a small amp for about $50 (a lot cheaper than buying an upright bass), you may also consider an acoustic bass guitar for $200 or more, as these can be played without an amp for practicing alone or with one other player, but will need amplification when with a band. Also, while many rock bassists use a guitar pick, get used to playing with your fingers, even at the beginning.
Mandolin – Simple string arrangement, with eight strings tuned as two strings to four different notes. Small enough, and for learning chords, probably perfect for a person wanting to learn an instrument popular with bluegrass but also distinctive. A-model mandolins can be had starting around $100 (although with a good set-up tack on at least $50 more), while the F-model mandolins start at around $300, also needing a good set-up. Like the guitar, quality models will run in the many thousands of dollars. As stated before, learning chords is easy, but solos on the smaller frets will be a challenge, and perfecting the “chop” strumming will take some time. Also, getting each pair of strings in tune with each other can be a pain.
Banjo – Bluegrass banjos stick to the five-string version, not the four-string plectrum or tenor models. Tuned to an open G chord, with that high fifth string, the skill comes with the coordination of the three picking fingers and the various rolls, peopularly known as the Scruggs style. Clawhammer style is also popluar, but is limited in a bluegrass band jam repertoire. Beginner banjos can be had for under $200 (these will usually have guitar tuning gears instead of the more durable and popular banjo tuning gears), with professional models going into the thousands. This is one instrument that will take some time to be competent enough to play with an ensemble, as you will be expected to play rolls without screwing up the tempo.
Fiddle – If you played violin in grade school, you are halfway there! Fiddle tuning is the same as classical violin (as well as the mandolin, by the way), and bowing is pretty much the same as well. What needs to be learned is the style of the fiddle. If not playing any solos yet, you will be either perfecting the chops like the mandolin, or doing two-note chords with long bowing.
Dobro – Like the banjo, all of the six strings are tuned to an open G chord. This one can be fun dragging the metal bar across the fretoard to get that sliding sound from the strings. Like the banjo, the technique is mostly in the three picking fingers, as well as placing the slide bar over the correct fret. Note that the strings are much higher off of the fretboard than a guitar, as there is no “fretting” with the fingers, just dragging the bar across the strings. With that said, dobros are also known as resonator guitars due to the metal cone on the body where the guitar soundhole is usually placed. You may see a resonator guitar for under $200, but this is usually a round-neck model, set up and to be played like a regular guitar. A bluegrass dobro will most likely have a square-backed neck, which makes it sturdier for the heavier strings and the raised string height. Of course, the dobro is played flat, with the strings and cone facing up for easier slidebar work. A squareneck dobro usually starts at about $300 for a beginner model, again with better models going into the thousands.
One question that came up was what instrument a singer should play. That again depends on comfort and what seems to be needed in the ensemble. Most of the time, you will see the lead singer toting an acoustic guitar, as it is the easiest to work with as just rhythm. However, you will see singers playing any of the above instruments, although the fingerpicking styles of the banjo and dobro require more attention than a lead singer can continually concentrate on.
Two easy ways to answer the question of a beginner bluegrass instrument is A.) See what seems to draw the most passion from you and your attention most, and B.) Try out every instrument that you have access to and see which one you are most comfortabe with as well as motivates you to wan tto learn it.
My next week’s blog may be late, as I will be on vacation in Nashville for that weekend.
Chew on it and comment.








